The Myth of Perfect Alignment: What Movement Science Really Tells Us

Episode 113 • November 16, 2026 • 00:24:32
The Myth of Perfect Alignment: What Movement Science Really Tells Us
Deepen Your Yoga Practice
The Myth of Perfect Alignment: What Movement Science Really Tells Us

Nov 16 2026 | 00:24:32

/

Hosted By

Lauren Leduc

Show Notes

Is there really a right way to do every yoga pose?

Stack your knee directly over your ankle. Square your hips. Keep your spine straight. Never let your knees travel past your toes. Make sure your heels touch the floor in Downward Facing Dog.

If you've practiced yoga for any length of time, you've probably heard some version of these instructions.

But what if the alignment rules we've come to associate with safety aren't quite as universal as we've been led to believe?

In this episode of Deepen Your Yoga Practice, Lauren explores the myth of perfect alignment and what movement science actually tells us about posture, anatomy, injury risk, and the remarkable adaptability of the human body.

Rather than dismissing alignment altogether, Lauren offers a more nuanced perspective: alignment is a valuable tool for understanding movement, distributing load, building capacity, and developing awareness. But there is no single, universally perfect position for every body, every posture, and every purpose.

In this episode, you'll explore:

Lauren also shares a simple experiment you can try during your next practice to explore how small changes in stance, foot position, or joint angles can influence your experience of a familiar posture.

Whether you're a yoga teacher questioning the cues you've inherited or a practitioner wondering why your body doesn't look like everyone else's in a pose, this episode invites you to move beyond aesthetics and develop a more intelligent, curious relationship with your body.

Alignment is a tool for exploration, not a standard of perfection.

Learn more about True Love Yoga and its teacher training programs: https://www.trueloveyogakc.com/yoga-teacher-training/

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:00] Foreign. [00:00:11] Welcome to deep in your yoga practice. I'm Lauren Leduc, the owner and founder of True Love Yoga in Kansas City, Missouri. And today we are deepening our practices by talking about the myth of perfect alignment. [00:00:24] So we'll talk about, when it comes to alignment, what movement science actually tells us, and we'll return to this again and again. There is no single universally perfect alignment for everybody in every posture, for every purpose. Alignment does matter, but its value comes from helping us understand movement, to distribute load and develop capacity and make informed choices, not from forcing everyone into an idealized shape. [00:00:55] And we can simplify it to this one sentence. [00:00:58] Alignment is a tool for exploration, not a standard of perfection. [00:01:04] I'm sure you've heard the following. [00:01:07] Stack your knee directly over your ankle. Square your hips, keep your spine straight. Don't let your knee travel past your toes. Make sure your feet are perfectly parallel. What if some of the rules we've been taught to associate with safe, corrective alignment aren't actually universal truths? Yoga has a rich tradition of very detailed posture instruction. But modern postural yoga has also inherited ideas and techniques from gymnastics, physical culture and changing anatomical theories. Many of us were taught to recognize a correct posture by its appearance. [00:01:45] And this can create an assumption that if a pose looks correct, it must be safe, and if it looks different, something must be wrong. But movement science presents a more nuanced picture. I know my own practice and my teaching has evolved over time with the more I learn and the more bodies I work with that when it comes to alignment, we're looking for the right alignment for that person that day. [00:02:14] We are not looking for a universal aesthetic and feeling of any particular posture. [00:02:24] We adapt for the individual to create more purposeful movement that is healthy and produces longevity. [00:02:34] I want to be clear from the beginning. I'm not suggesting that alignment doesn't matter at all. I'm just suggesting that we need a more sophisticated understanding of what alignment is actually for. [00:02:45] But before we can talk about good alignment, we need to examine what makes an alignment ideal in the first place. [00:02:53] First quote, unquote, perfect alignment is a myth. There is a difference between alignment and idealized alignment. Alignment is the relationship between body segments and how we organize ourselves for a movement or position. So how the body organizes itself in space and alignment cue, like where to put parts of the body, can help somebody direct force through a particular joint or muscle group. [00:03:23] It can help them find balance and stability, maybe access or reduce movement demand. It can help a student develop awareness and coordination. [00:03:34] And it can help a student adjust the posture to better serve its purpose in their body. [00:03:40] But none of these automatically establishes one universally correct position. [00:03:46] We'll talk about some assumptions that are worth challenging. The first one is that everyone should look the same in a pose. It is so important to know that human bodies differ so much. There is so much variation in proportions and joint structure, in mobility and strength and movement history and genetics. [00:04:08] That why would everyone look the same in the same pose? [00:04:12] The next assumption would be that neutral alignment is always safest. [00:04:17] What we do know is that neutral can be a very useful reference position. [00:04:22] But it isn't a universal requirement for safe movement. Our joints and tissues are built to experience movement Through a range of positions. [00:04:32] The next assumption would be that good alignment prevents injury. [00:04:36] We can really know that technique can influence loading and performance. But injury risk is multifactorial. [00:04:44] Particular, visible alignment cannot guarantee protection from injury. We can't always see what's going on in the inside. [00:04:52] So know that there is this difference. Between a position being unfamiliar and challenging and uncomfortable and inherently dangerous. So if something is new, if something challenges you, if something provides a certain level of discomfort, that doesn't mean you're going to get hurt. [00:05:12] In our individual anatomy as humans, again, there is so much variation. And this is going to affect how we move. It's going to affect alignment, posture, angles, et cetera. Our actual bones themselves influence these movement possibilities. [00:05:33] So it's easy to think that if I just stretch my muscles enough, Eventually I'll be able to do xyz, maybe the splits, or a perfect wheel pose, something like that. [00:05:47] But the truth is, there is so much variation. Within the way our bones are shaped and how they fit together. [00:05:54] This might be in your femur or thigh bone. [00:05:58] And your hip socket orientation, like how the femur fits into the hip socket. And even the size of the hip socket and depth. We can have different relative lengths of our torso, of our legs, of our arms. [00:06:12] We have a lot of differentiation in shoulder anatomy and available overhead motion. That has nothing to do with muscles or fascia. It's all to do with bone. And we have individual joint mobility, which is influenced by how the bones are shaped, how they fit together, or congruence and elasticity of the ligaments. [00:06:34] So these different variations in skeletal structure. Can influence how people experience postures. [00:06:40] Even when they are equally measured in strength and skill. [00:06:45] Let's take a squat, for instance. Or in yoga, we might say Malasana. [00:06:51] 2. Different people might require different widths of the feet, different angles of the feet, and different heel elevations. To find something that is comfortable and functional. [00:07:04] If we start adding weight, this might also vary upon where the resistance is coming from or where you are holding the weight. [00:07:13] So I'll add, for me, when I am finding a squat, I have very long femurs or thigh bones. [00:07:20] It's hard for me to sit back without leaning forward a little bit. So if I'm doing a heavy back squat, for instance, it is really helpful for me to take my shoes off and elevate my heels. [00:07:35] I feel more grounded in my feet and I'm able to stay more upright when I do this. [00:07:41] Also, in malasana or a yogic squat, I have a lot of external rotation mobility in my femurs and through my hip sockets. So my toes can be quite wide. I can have a lot of rotation through my feet and I can sit really, really low without my heels lifting and it's very comfortable. But that's not going to feel the same for somebody with less external rotational mobility, maybe with less ankle mobility. [00:08:13] And again, that might have nothing to do with pliability of the muscles. And when two postures are expressed differently in different bodies, we know that neither shape is automatically superior. One is not better than the other. It's what is best for this individual. [00:08:32] The way that our joints fit might change mechanical demands a little bit. [00:08:37] For instance, downward facing dog, we talk about having the humerus bones or upper arm bones in an external rotation, but students and people are going to have very different levels of external rotation based on genetics, lifestyle, etc. So maybe one student needs to be a little bit more internally rotated or they need to flare their hands out a little bit. [00:09:04] Where do their shoulders feel most stable and comfortable as opposed to achieving a very, very specific look. Additionally, in downward facing dog, students are going to experience different levels of shoulder flexion of ability in their upper spine or mobility in their upper spine, pardon, thoracic mobility in their hamstring length or tension and ankle mobility. [00:09:30] And this will influence the overall shape. [00:09:33] So saying that heels have to be on the mat and downward facing dog is not true. Because what are we trying to do in downward facing Dog? Generally, we're trying to stabilize the shoulders and decompress the spine. [00:09:49] It can feel so good to do an aligned down dog for you after a long day of sitting, for instance. [00:09:56] And so for some students, to achieve the decompression, they need to bend their knees deeply and lift their heels off of the mat. Again, it doesn't make it inherently better or worse than a down dog where somebody's heels are on the mat, it is just different, and it's smart. It's also important to note that these anatomical variations create different possibilities within the body. They're not these. These fixed destinies. [00:10:25] So just because your bones are a certain way doesn't mean that you can't do xyz. Posture movement is shaped both by this inherent structure of the body, but also the adaptable qualities of the body. [00:10:41] We are very adaptable to strength, to coordination, to stretch tolerance. [00:10:47] So we certainly can quote, unquote make progress. Over time, we can get stronger. We can feel more easeful within postures by tending to our practices and taking advantage of these adaptable qualities. [00:11:04] So we can make a goal not to make our bodies fit a specific pose, but perhaps instead to understand what the pose is asking of the body, to vary the way that we approach it, and to develop an understanding and relationship with it that is beyond aesthetic. It's also important to note, like I said earlier, that quote unquote misalignment and pain aren't always interlinked. [00:11:35] Posture in and of itself is not a reliable standalone predictor of pain. [00:11:42] So we might think, my back hurts because I sit incorrectly. But it could be a whole lot more complex than that. [00:11:49] Pain can be influenced by tissue irritation or injury, by the amount of load we put the body under and the amount of recovery that we give it. [00:11:58] By previous experiences, by sleep and stress, the sensitivity of the nervous system, also by our beliefs and expectations about movement. [00:12:10] So our nociception or perception of pain can very much be mentally influenced or programmed by our beliefs. And pain can be influenced by overall health and individual circumstances. [00:12:24] So is pain real? Absolutely. Don't tell me it's not. But it can't always be explained by a single visible movement pattern or quote, unquote misalignment. [00:12:38] We talked about how the body is quite adaptable in a lot of ways. And when it comes to that, we need to consider that capacity and load matter quite a bit. Our tissues respond to the demands placed upon them, and those demands need to be appropriately dosed. An unfamiliar position may be tolerable at a low load, but really challenging under fatigue or high resistance. Likewise, a technically polished movement may still exceed someone's current capacity if the load intensity or volume is too high. That means a movement isn't automatically safe just because it looks pretty. And it isn't automatically dangerous because it looks unconventional. I grew up dancing, and so much of dance is led by aesthetics. It's an art, it's beautiful. [00:13:32] But the movement isn't necessarily Designed for health. [00:13:36] So you won't always see longevity in a dancer's career because of the demand put upon their body to create that very specific aesthetic. [00:13:46] So again, it may look beautiful, it may look graceful, but that doesn't always uncover what's happening behind the scenes. And movement variability, whether it's pretty or not, is very, very useful for us. So it's so important to move the body in many different ways. [00:14:04] They don't need to, and they can't occupy one ideal position all day. [00:14:10] When we change positions, it can distribute demands placed on the body. It can expose us to different movement experiences and can provide opportunities to develop adaptability. [00:14:21] But also, just moving differently all the time isn't inherently better either. We don't need to come to the mat, for instance, and do a different, unpredictable vinyasa practice each and every time. [00:14:35] Repetition and consistency can be very, very valuable for skill development. [00:14:42] And when we're doing this, we can repeat a familiar movement or sequence, but it doesn't necessarily mean we're trying to produce the exact same external, perfect shape every time. Instead, we're developing awareness and skill and. And capacity to make increasingly intelligent choices. [00:15:02] So should we just throw alignment out the window? That's a no as well. [00:15:08] This is nuanced. Alignment can be especially important when specific joint or tissue is irritated. [00:15:16] For when a student is recovering from injury. For when a movement requires strict precision for the performance of it, meaning performing something quite challenging probably needs to be done in a quite precise way. [00:15:32] Doing something with resistance or bearing load also should be done in quite a precise way for that particular person's body for safety. Alignment is very important when a practitioner is working near their strength or mobility limits. So when we're pushing our bodies to the limits, alignment becomes increasingly important because of distribution of load. [00:15:59] Alignment is super important. When a position consistently provokes pain or symptoms, it's a good indication to change the alignment and find something that's more ideal. And alignment's also really important when we are trying to target a particular muscle group or movement pattern. [00:16:16] I absolutely love cueing alignment. I find it so, so much fun. But my goal is to help students find alignment that works for their individual body, rather than trying to make everyone look like clones and achieve the same level of mobility and strength. Because, long story short, we are all different. [00:16:37] So what should alignment cues actually do? Well, I think we can move from strict rules to invitations, so bringing more awareness to what is happening within the individual. [00:16:49] So instead of saying something like, never let your knee go past your toes, you could Say something like, notice how shifting your knee changes the demand on your ankle and thigh. [00:17:02] So it's inviting in discernment and observation. [00:17:07] Maybe instead of saying, keep your spine perfectly straight, you might say something like, explore the position of your spine and choose what supports the movement we're doing. [00:17:17] Maybe that's lengthening the spine. Maybe that's finding the natural curves within the spine. [00:17:23] Maybe instead of saying something like, your heels must touch the floor, we could say, let your heels move toward the floor without forcing them. Or suggest placing a block or blanket under the heels if that feels grounding for the student. [00:17:37] So I have three questions that yoga teachers should ask when it comes to cueing alignment. [00:17:44] And the first one would be, what is the intention of this posture? Is it strength, balance, mobility, relaxation, coordination? Or is it something else? Next is, what is the student actually experiencing? [00:17:59] So what can they feel? What can they control? What can they tolerate here? [00:18:03] And finally, what adjustment would help them achieve the intention? So changing the stance, the range, the load, support, tempo, what would help create more stability and ease within the posture? [00:18:19] Something teachers can do as well, is give internal and external cues when guiding alignment. So I don't mean internal like interoception. What I mean is going a little bit deeper, like specifying the muscles rather than the movement pattern. So, so an internal cue might be, engage your quadriceps or engage the front of your thighs, and this helps straighten the leg. [00:18:45] And external cue could be to press the floor away. [00:18:50] So we're using the floor as our point of reference, something external rather than our own bodies. Both of these can be really, really useful. External focus cues often support motor performance and learning in certain contexts, while internal cues can help when attention to a specific body region is the teaching objective. So are we bringing awareness to this region, or are we learning how to move the body in a very specific way and learn that movement pattern? I'll touch briefly on the context of hands on assists within this. [00:19:27] Hands on assists are not about sculpting somebody into the teacher's preferred shape. Hands on assists are a service to students. [00:19:36] They should have a clear purpose, always be consensual, of course, and respect that particular student's autonomy and comfort and anatomical variation. [00:19:47] So the best adjustment isn't necessarily the one that makes the pose look better. It's the one that makes the practice more meaningful for the person who is doing it. [00:19:57] I do want to tie some yogic philosophy in because in my opinion, it really strengthens the case of movement science. [00:20:06] So one point of philosophy that is overarchingly so important in yoga is ahimsa or non harming. So when alignment becomes rigid or fear based, we may unintentionally teach students to distrust their bodies. [00:20:22] Instead, ahimsa invites us to consider not only the physical demands of a posture or movement, but also the language and beliefs that we're reinforcing within the student. [00:20:33] Another important philosophical concept is swadiaya ya or self study. [00:20:38] So as a student you might ask yourself instead of does my posture look correct? [00:20:45] Instead, what am I noticing? Where do I feel effort? [00:20:49] Where do I feel ease? What happens if I change this position? [00:20:53] Is this serving my intention for the practice? And this helps you become a very active participant in your own yogic practice rather than someone to be molded or shaped by a teacher. I also want to bring in Sutra 112 which is the fluctuations of the mind are stilled through practice and non attachment of Abiasa and Vragya. With abiasa we practice consistently, we refine our technique and we build skills. And with viragia we release attachment to how a posture is supposed to look or what achieving it says about us. We can deeply care about how we practice without becoming attached to a perfect looking result. [00:21:37] Lastly, I want to bring up verse246 of the Sutras which is serum sukham Asanam Sarah meaning effort, Sukha meaning ease, Asanam is the posture. So the posture should be practice with both steadiness and ease. And just like practice and non attachment, yogic philosophy is full of these dichotomies of this balance or blending of seemingly opponent opposing concepts. [00:22:07] So how can we in our movement and in each posture find steadiness or effort or strength? And how do we find the ease, the release, the calm? While the sutras spoke about simply the posture of meditation, we can apply this to all of our movement and all of our asana within yoga and other practices as well. Even if the ease, even if the non attachment is simply something that's happening mentally sometimes. [00:22:40] So I'll give you an experiment to try Next time you practice, choose a familiar posture to you, like Warrior two or Downward Dog or Chair pose and try three different variations. [00:22:51] The first one is your usual alignment. Variation two would be changing one variable that might be your width, your foot angle or the bend of your knee. Variation three is to make a second small adjustment and observe the difference. [00:23:07] And then you can ask yourself where do I feel the effort? [00:23:10] Does this variation change my balance? Which position helps me achieve my intention? [00:23:16] Is one version more comfortable or is it simply more familiar? [00:23:21] I do encourage as you experiment and practice in this way to do it in a gradual and comfortable way rather than choosing an extreme difference and pushing into pain. So this can be very subtle. It might not even be that noticeable from the outside but likely you'll feel a difference on the inside. [00:23:41] So to reiterate, alignment isn't meaningless, it's just not universal. It is a way of understanding and organizing movement but it's not a measure of our worth or how advanced we are as practitioners. If you're a yoga teacher listening today, I hope this gives you permission to be curious about the cues you've inherited. [00:24:00] Not because everything you've learned is wrong but because the practice of teaching yoga should evolve alongside our understanding of the human body. [00:24:08] So how can we Deepen Your Practice by becoming less attached to perfect alignment and more interested in understanding our own bodies. [00:24:18] Thank you so much for joining this exploration with me today. [00:24:22] Until next time, Om Shanti Om Peace.

Other Episodes

Episode 8

October 07, 2024 • 00:32:44
Episode Cover

Finding Stillness: Katie Brown on Yin Yoga and Overcoming Body Image Challenges

Summary In this episode, Lauren Leduc interviews Katie Brown, a yoga and mindfulness specialist, about her journey into yoga and her passion for yin...

Listen

Episode 68

December 01, 2025 • 00:12:35
Episode Cover

The Five Currents of Life: Exploring the Prana Vayus

✨ Shownotes In this episode of Deepen Your Yoga Practice, Lauren Leduc dives into the Prana Vayus, the five vital energy currents within the...

Listen

Episode 35

April 14, 2025 • 00:18:23
Episode Cover

Your Practice, On the Page: Deepening Insight Through the Yoga Practice Journal

In this episode of Deepen Your Yoga Practice, Lauren Leduc discusses the significance of journaling in yoga, emphasizing how it can enhance self-reflection and...

Listen